TOPSHOT - Former Elysee senior security officer Alexandre Benalla (L) arrives to speak to the senatorial commission in Paris on September 19, 2018. - Benalla, who was videotaped beating up a protester, will is appearing before a Senate commission examining the resulting political scandal. The commission wants to understand the nature of Benalla's job at the presidential Elysee Palace, which gave him perks and let him carry a gun, as well as uncover eventual malfunctions in the office of top aides and the security details protecting the president. (Photo by Alain JOCARD / AFP)